Place · river

Syr Darya

What the sources say here: 7 passages

Mud ruins the Kazakhs credited to the Nogais

Editorial contextAlong a dried-up river channel Meyendorff saw long earth mounds with canals and broken pottery, the remains of buildings of sun-dried brick. The Kazakhs could not say when or why they were built but guessed they were the work of the Nogais, who had held the steppe before them. The best-known ruin, Djankend, was of fired brick and said to be the seat of an Oghuz chief.

It is clear these buildings, whatever they may have been, were built with sun-burnt bricks; near these ruins are small canals about 1 toise or 6 feet broad and two deep; a great quantity of broken pottery is also to be met with. … The Kirghiz could give us no account of their use or date, but supposing they must have been erected by the Nogais

Georg von Meyendorff (translated by William Monteith, 1840)

About Kazakhs; earlier Nogais and Oghuz

Keep in mind

The attribution to the Nogais is the Kazakhs' guess, as Meyendorff says.

Continue in this sourceThe Russian embassy's march from Orenburg to Bukhara1820 to 1821 · 14 passages

Songs to the moon by the Syr Darya

Editorial contextWintering among the reeds of the Syr Darya was the Kazakhs' great wish. Meyendorff describes men sitting half the night on a stone, gazing at the moon and singing sad improvised songs, and regrets never hearing the heroic songs that only professional bards performed.

The Kirghiz often pass half the night seated on a stone, gazing at the moon, and singing melancholy impromptu words to airs not less so. They also have historical songs, which celebrate the great actions of their heroes, but these are chaunted only by professional singers, and I greatly regret not having heard them.

Georg von Meyendorff (translated by William Monteith, 1840)

About Kazakhs (Kirghiz)

Continue in this sourceThe Russian embassy's march from Orenburg to Bukhara1820 to 1821 · 14 passages

Every unknown ruin 'comes from the Tatars'

Editorial contextRiding through saxaul woods, the caravan passed ruins of 'an earlier town or fortress'. Eversmann saw walls of sun-dried bricks four to five inches thick mixed with some fired ones, two window openings with pointed arches in the largest building, three rings of walls now slumped into banks, and many unglazed potsherds. The Kazakhs called the place Kutschuk and said the Tatars built it, but he warns that they credit everything unknown in their steppe to the Tatars simply because the Tatars lived there just before them.

These ruins, which were probably once a fortress, are called Kutschuk by the Kirghiz and are supposed, as they claim, to come from the Tatars; but their statement is not to be relied on at all: they make everything that is unknown to them in their steppe come from the Tatars, because these lived there immediately before them.

Working translation

Original wording

Diese Ruinen, die wahrscheinlich früher eine Festung gewesen sind, werden von den Kirgisen Kutschuk genannt, und sollen, wie sie behaupten, von den Tataren herstammen; aber auf ihre Aussage ist durchaus nicht zu bauen, sie lassen alles, was ihnen in ihrer Steppe unbekannt ist, von den Tataren herstammen, weil diese zunächst vor ihnen dort gehaust haben.

Eduard Eversmann

About Kazakhs (Kirghiz) as informants; 'Tatars' as the supposed builders

Continue in this sourceEversmann's journey from Orenburg to Bukhara, 1820 to 18211820 to 1821 · 10 passages

Ruined cities on the Syr Darya

Editorial contextRiding east, Carpini crossed the old Khwarazmian lands the Mongols had conquered in 1219 to 1221 and found them full of ruins. He names Ianckint, Barchin and Ornas. Rockhill's footnote on the same page quotes Carpini's longer account of how the Mongols took Ornas by diverting the river and flooding the city, and on the page before Carpini describes skulls and bones lying on the steppe 'like cattle-dung'.

We found in that country innumerable ruined cities, overthrown villages, and many deserted towns. There is a great river in that country whose name I do not know, and on which stands a city called Ianckint, and also another called Barchin, and still another called Ornas

John of Pian de Carpine (translated by W. W. Rockhill, 1900)

About Bisermins (Muslims of the Khwarazmian lands), conquered by the Tartars

Keep in mind

Identifications of Ornas (Otrar or Urgench) are uncertain; see Rockhill's note.

Continue in this sourceFriar William's journey to the Mongol court, with Carpini and Benedict the Pole1245 to 1255 · 21 passages
Show 3 more passages

Domed steppe tombs built by hired Bukharans

Editorial contextEversmann describes the typical larger Kazakh tomb of the southern steppe: a round building with a domed cupola topped by a small pillar, a projecting entrance with a pointed arch and four attached corner pillars. They were mostly of unfired brick, sometimes rubble, all quite new, and built by Bukharans whom the Kazakhs paid in sheep or grain. He mentions them only because Europeans imagined such things very differently; poorer graves where there is no stone were gabled vaults of clay. A footnote says Pallas drew the 'Tatar tombs' of southern Russia in just the same way.

They are mostly built of unfired bricks, sometimes also of rubble stone. All these tombs are very new and were built by Bukharans, whose labour the Kirghiz pay either in sheep or in grain … The whole thing is, moreover, a most wretched piece of work, and I mention it only because in Europe people imagine such things quite differently from what they really are.

Working translation

Original wording

Sie sind grösstentheils von ungebrannten Ziegeln aufgebaut, mitunter auch von Bruchsteinen. Alle diese Grabmähler sind sehr neu und von Bucharen aufgebaut, denen ihre Mühe von den Kirgisen entweder mit Schaafen oder mit Getraide bezahlt wird … Das Ganze ist übrigens ein höchst erbärmliches Machwerk, und ich führe es nur bloss deshalb an, weil man sich in Europa dergleichen Dinge ganz anders vorstellt, als sie wirklich sind.

Eduard Eversmann

About Kazakhs (Kirghiz) as patrons; Bukharans as builders

Keep in mind

The dismissive judgement of the workmanship is Eversmann's taste; the facts about materials and builders are his observation and inquiry.

Continue in this sourceEversmann's journey from Orenburg to Bukhara, 1820 to 18211820 to 1821 · 10 passages

Otrar: where the war began

Editorial contextYelü Chucai names Otrar ('O-ta-la'), ruling more than ten other towns, as the cause of the Mongol invasion of Central Asia. Its governor had Chinggis Khan's envoys and several hundred merchants with them killed and seized their goods. Bretschneider notes that Persian historians tell the same story.

One time the chief of this place ordered several envoys (of Chinghiz), and several hundreds of merchants (who were with them), to be put to death, and seized upon their goods. That was the cause of the army being directed against the Western people.

Yelü Chucai's Si yu lu, in a Yuan-era abridgement (translated by E. Bretschneider, 1888)

About Chinggis Khan's envoys and merchants; the governor of Otrar

Continue in this sourceYelü Chucai's Record of a Journey to the West1219 to 1224 · 4 passages

Breath that froze on the beard

Editorial contextOn Timur's last march toward China, Ibn Arabshah describes a winter so cold that a man's breath froze on his moustache and beard, and spittle turned to a frozen pellet before it hit the ground. It is a set piece of rhymed prose about the winter in which Timur died at Otrar.

When a man breathed out, his breath froze on his moustache and beard … and if he spat phlegm from his mouth, for all its warmth it did not reach the ground except as a frozen pellet.

Working translation

Original wording

وكان الرجل اذا تنفس جمدت انفاسه على سباله ولحيته … وان لفظ من فيه نخامة لا تصل الى الارض مع ما فيها من الحرارة الا وهي بندقة جامدة

Ahmad ibn Arabshah (Arabic text, print catalogued 1842)

About Timur's army (Chaghatay Turks and Tatars)

Keep in mind

Literary exaggeration; Ibn Arabshah was not on the campaign.

Transcribed from the page image (corpus OCR of this print is garbled); vowel marks and the asterisk dividers of the rhymed prose omitted.

Continue in this sourceIbn Arabshah's hostile life of Timur, with the Golden Horde from inside1401 to 1422 · 12 passages

3 sources and maps name this place

  1. 1072–1077a range
    Compendium of the Turkic Dialects
    WMahmud al-KashgarifirsthandW219
  2. 1659–1661a range
    Genealogy of the Turkmen
    WAbu'l-Ghazi Bahadur KhancompilationW209
  3. 1823–1832a range